For many Airbnb hosts, a 4-star review can feel almost as frustrating as a negative one. The stay may have gone smoothly, there were no complaints, and the guest even left positive comments — yet the rating still falls short of five stars.
Understanding why guests leave 4-star reviews is essential, especially because Airbnb’s algorithm heavily favours consistently high ratings. Over time, repeated 4-star reviews can affect visibility, ranking, and booking performance.
This article explores the most common reasons guests leave 4-star reviews — and what hosts can do to prevent them.
The Airbnb Rating Problem Most Guests Don’t Understand
One of the biggest challenges is that guests often interpret Airbnb ratings differently from hosts.
To many guests:
-
5 stars means “exceptional or luxury”
-
4 stars means “good and as expected”
-
3 stars means “average”
To Airbnb:
-
5 stars = acceptable and competitive
-
4 stars = underperforming
-
Repeated 4-star ratings = reduced visibility
This disconnect is at the heart of the problem.
Common Reasons Guests Leave 4-Star Reviews
1. Expectations Didn’t Fully Match Reality
Even small mismatches can lead to a 4-star rating:
-
The property felt smaller than expected
-
The location was quieter or busier than imagined
-
Photos appeared brighter or more spacious
Guests may still enjoy their stay but feel it didn’t “wow” them.
How to fix it:
Ensure listings are accurate, not aspirational. Clear photos, honest descriptions, and realistic wording help prevent disappointment.
2. “Everything Was Fine, But Nothing Stood Out”
Many guests leave 4 stars simply because nothing went wrong — but nothing felt special either.
From a guest’s perspective, a smooth stay is expected, not exceptional.
How to fix it:
Add small touches that create a memorable experience:
-
A welcome note
-
Local recommendations
-
Thoughtful extras like tea, coffee, or toiletries
These small details often push guests toward a 5-star rating.
3. Minor Issues That Didn’t Feel Worth Complaining About
Guests may not report small issues during their stay but will mention them afterward:
-
Low water pressure
-
Slight noise
-
Slow Wi-Fi
-
Confusing heating controls
They didn’t ruin the stay — but they affected the rating.
How to fix it:
Encourage guests to report issues during their stay and respond quickly. Most guests reward proactive problem-solving with higher ratings.
4. Price Sensitivity and Value Perception
Some guests rate based on value, not quality.
Even if the stay was good, guests may think: “It was nice, but slightly expensive for what we got.”
How to fix it:
-
Ensure pricing matches the experience
-
Highlight what’s included
-
Avoid hidden or unexpected fees
Clear value communication helps justify the price.
5. Location Misunderstandings
Location is one of the most common causes of 4-star reviews, even when it’s clearly stated.
Guests may underestimate:
-
Travel time
-
Noise levels
-
Local amenities
How to fix it:
Be extremely clear about:
-
Distance to transport
-
Neighbourhood type
-
Who the location is best suited for
Clarity filters out the wrong guests and protects ratings.
6. Guests Think 4 Stars Is a Compliment
Many guests genuinely believe they are leaving a positive review by selecting 4 stars.
They may even write: “Great stay, would recommend!”
Yet still choose 4 stars without realising the impact.
How to fix it:
Educate gently and professionally. A short message before checkout can help:
“Airbnb considers 5-star reviews as meeting expectations. If anything can be improved, please let us know during your stay.”
How Hosts Can Reduce 4-Star Reviews Long-Term
Set Expectations Clearly
Honest listings attract the right guests and reduce disappointment.
Over-Communicate the Essentials
Check-in instructions, heating, Wi-Fi, parking — confusion leads to lower ratings.
Fix Small Issues Fast
Speed matters more than perfection.
Ask for Feedback Before Checkout
This gives you a chance to resolve issues before a review is written.
Focus on Consistency
Reliable cleanliness, comfort, and communication matter more than luxury.
Final Thoughts
4-star reviews are rarely a sign of failure — they’re usually a signal that expectations, communication, or guest understanding need adjustment.
By improving clarity, adding small value-boosting touches, and proactively communicating with guests, hosts can steadily convert 4-star stays into 5-star reviews.
In today’s competitive Airbnb market, that small difference can have a big impact on rankings, visibility, and long-term success.
